Socialist Worker

Victory for Iraq war resisters in Canada

Issue No. 2082

US war resisters – soldiers who fled to Canada rather than serve in Iraq – have won a significant victory in their campaign for asylum.

A key committee in the Canadian parliament has ruled that the soldiers had the right to refuse to serve in a war if it is not sanctioned by the United Nations.

The committee, which includes members of Canada’s ruling Liberal Party, recommended that the government allow Iraq war resisters and their families to stay in Canada. It also called for an immediate halt to all deportation proceedings.

This ruling came after the committee heard the testimony of former US army sergeant Philip McDowell.


McDowell joined the army in 2001 following the 9/11 attacks on the US. He served a year in Iraq, ending his tour of duty in March 2005.

But a month and a half after being discharged, he was ordered back into the army under the notorious “stop-loss” policy which allows the US army to re‑enlist former soldiers.

Disillusioned with the war, McDowell fled to Canada in October 2006 where he joined a growing number of soldiers who have refused to join the illegal occupation.

He told a recent anti-war rally that “thousands of soldiers in the military have told me that they feel the same way”.

The committee’s vote has boosted the chances of asylum following a ruling by Canada’s supreme court that shut the door on sanctuary for resisters.

The resolution must now be taken up by Canada’s House of Commons when it returns from its winter break in early February.

Michelle Robidoux, one of the organisers of the war resisters’ campaign told supporters, “I want to make sure that nobody leaves thinking that this is won. It’s very important that we understand that now the work begins.

“This does not mean that people can stay immediately. But it does means that there is a significant political opening.”

For more on the campaign go to »

Click here to subscribe to our daily morning email newsletter 'Breakfast in red'

Article information

Mon 17 Dec 2007, 17:16 GMT
Issue No. 2082
Share this article


Mobile users! Don't forget to add Socialist Worker to your home screen.