Socialist Worker

Iraq inquiry aims to let warmongers off the hook

by Jim Brann, a national officer of the Stop the War Coalition
Issue No. 2163

In mid-June Gordon Brown announced that there would be a “non-judgmental”, behind-closed-doors inquiry into the Iraq war, conducted by hand-picked insiders.

On Thursday 30 July, responding to widespread criticism, the latest version of the inquiry was announced.

The chairman, Sir John Chilcot, a former top civil servant and staff counsellor for the security and intelligence agencies, said that “as much as poss­ible” of the evidence would now be heard in pub­lic.

He implied that would include Tony Blair’s evid­ence.

Chilcot said the inquiry will begin taking evidence this autumn. Its final report may not come out until 2011.

Chilcot said, “The independence of the members of this inquiry, I think, can’t reasonably be challeng­ed”.

But its members are the same insiders announced by Brown in June. Chilcot said that it would not be “helpful” to discuss questions like whether any of them had opposed the Iraq war.

Chilcot himself was a member of the Butler inquiry, which cleared Blair of dishonestly using intellig­ence in the run-up to the Iraq war.

Other members of the inquiry include historian Sir Law­rence Freedman, who helped Blair develop the doctrine of “liberal interventionism” that he used to justify the war.

Historian Sir Martin Gilbert, who wrote an article in 2004 saying Blair and George Bush could one day be compared to Churchill and Roosevelt, is also a member of the inquiry.

The events covered by the inquiry will go back only to the summer of 2001.

Yet US governments have aimed to overthrow the Iraqi government since 1998.

Chilcot has limited the scope of the inquiry to dealing with “mistakes” and “shortcomings” on the road to war and its aftermath.

The inquiry will have no legal powers. No evid­ence will be taken on oath and no perjury charges can be brought.

The inquiry will not even employ its own barrister to cross-examine witnesses.

But there will still be some private hearings, “to ensure candour and openness from witnesses”.

The cards are stacked in favour of an in­quiry that concludes that “mistakes were made” and they should be “learned from” next time.

It is unlikely that the over one million dead and four and a half million refugees will get much of a look in either.

But there is scope for the anti-war movement to intervene in this cosy process.

The Stop the War Coalition plans to give evidence—and groups and individuals should submit theirs too.

Click here to subscribe to our daily morning email newsletter 'Breakfast in red'

Article information

Tue 4 Aug 2009, 19:27 BST
Issue No. 2163
Share this article


Mobile users! Don't forget to add Socialist Worker to your home screen.