Socialist Worker

Citizen Khan: a significant TV moment, but not one for comedy

The BBC’s first Asian sitcom is just like every other bad sitcom, says Jas Blackwell-Pal

Issue No. 2318

Citizen Khan is the BBC’s first sitcom about a Muslim family

Citizen Khan is the BBC’s first sitcom about a Muslim family


The BBC launches Citizen Khan this week, created by and starring former radio presenter Adil Ray.

As the first ever British Asian sitcom it marks a significant event in the history of British television. Unfortunately, it is not a very significant event for comedy.

While the concept of a show based around a Muslim family in Birmingham might sound groundbreaking, the jokes definitely are not. In fact, Citizen Khan manages to style itself like every other bad sitcom you can think of. It’s complete with toilet gags, ginger jokes and canned laughter.

The show follows an age old formula, giving us tired and clichéd storylines like Mr Khan losing his mother-in-law in the shopping centre. This means that we witness the same offensive jokes we’ve seen since the 1960s, just coming from the mouths of Muslim characters instead.

We see Mr Khan laughing at the “funny” accent of a Somalian man and complaining about the influx of Eastern European immigrants. Such jokes could be a funny way of shedding light on how minorities are turned against each other, but they are just painful to watch.

The acting is laughable—and as someone who grew up close to Sparkhill, where the show is set, I can tell you that the accents are unrecognisable.

This is somewhat surprising because, although Citizen Khan is the first Asian sitcom, the BBC does have a history of producing great Asian comedy.

Observation

In the 1990s they ran the sketch show Goodness Gracious Me, which managed to be both a smart observation of multicultural Britain and also hilarious.

Crucially, Goodness Gracious Me offered not only scenes which an Asian audience could recognise, but also turned the jokes towards the casual racism which they faced everyday.

One of the best sketches involved a group of young Indian friends deciding to go out “for an English”. They show up drunk, order the “blandest thing on the menu” and mispronounce the name of the waiter.

While it’s sad that there are few examples of Asian comedy to look to, Citizen Khan doesn’t exactly offer a recipe for more. Not only is the humour terrible but the show actually says very little about the experience of Muslims.

The designers have clearly gone to great effort to make the Khan’s house seem as authentic as possible, and some people will laugh as they see the familiar sight of plastic covers left on sofas.

But other than superficial nods, it’s as if the writers are so terrified of causing controversy that they have deliberately made the show indistinguishable from other British sitcoms.

What a shame. We should applaud the fact that a programme like this has been made—but lament the fact that it is so bad.

Citizen Khan shows on Mondays from 27 August, BBC One, 10.20pm


Click here to subscribe to our daily morning email newsletter 'Breakfast in red'

Article information

Reviews
Tue 28 Aug 2012, 16:56 BST
Issue No. 2318
Share this article


Mobile users! Don't forget to add Socialist Worker to your home screen.