Socialist Worker

The Other Side Of Hope puts refugees’ struggles in a cold context

by Dave Sewell
Issue No. 2557

Khaled played by Sherwan Haji

Khaled played by Sherwan Haji


The Other Side of Hope
Directed by Aki Kaurismaki
On general release

Well over a million people have been shoved through Europe’s “reception centres” since the refugee crisis began in 2015. Yet it’s remarkable how little impact this has had on the big screen.

This drily absurd sort of comedy does its bit to address that gap.

It contrasts the ordeal of Khaled (Sherwan Haji), a mechanic fleeing war-torn Aleppo, with salesman Wikstrom’s (Sakari Kuosmanen) attempt to change career.

In many ways it’s a follow on to Kaurismaki’s 2011 gentle comedy Le Havre.

It uses many of the same techniques, notably a jarringly surreal choice of props.

The Good Postman—a Bulgarian village where solidarity shone through
The Good Postman—a Bulgarian village where solidarity shone through
  Read More

And it echoes Le Havre’s celebration of many ordinary people’s instinctive solidarity with the refugees they are supposed to fear or hate.

But this is a much colder, sadder film.

Deliberately artificial staging and camerawork makes the characters look lonely and fragile, boxed in or locked out by a bureaucratic world.

This studied awkwardness also sharpens the deadpan humour of many scenes.

And it creates an unflinching honesty about the horrors refugees face—family separation, poverty, fascist violence and police repression.

The understated acting leaves the frequent musical interludes—from rock’n’roll buskers to Khaled himself on a borrowed oud—to provide the emotional warmth.

But in its own wry way The Other Side of Hope argues powerfully against the cruel hypocrisy of immigration controls, and for faith in human solidarity to overcome them.


Click here to subscribe to our daily morning email newsletter 'Breakfast in red'

Mobile users! Don't forget to add Socialist Worker to your home screen.