Socialist Worker

Blood scandal inquiry hears how Thatcher’s Tories resisted payouts to victims

Issue No. 2774

The NHS and the state have for years sought to cover up the contaminated blood scandal

The NHS and the state have for years sought to cover up the contaminated blood scandal


Margaret Thatcher’s Tory government was determined to resist compensation for people infected with HIV through blood transplants because ministers feared it would set a precedent.

Former health secretary Norman Fowler told the inquiry into the contaminated blood scandal this week that campaigners for a pay-out were “doomed to failure”. “There was no chance that I was going to get permission to do that, no chance whatsoever,” he said.

“The treasury was against it, the prime minister would have been against it because she would have been told that it would have other effects.”

“It was a hopeless case I’m afraid because they took the view that, if agreed to, the floodgates would have been opened.”

Some 1,240 NHS patients with haemophilia were among the victims of the scandal. Most were infected with HIV or hepatitis through a blood product known as Factor 8, much of which was bought untreated from the US.

Most of the patients have since died.

The NHS and the state have for years sought to cover up the scandal.

Reveal 

Doctors refused to reveal to patients the real reason for their HIV infections. Medical records were destroyed. And former health ministers continue to insist no one at the time knew that unscreened blood was dangerous.

The inquiry also heard that Thatcher’s private secretary, Mark Addison, advised her not to attend the 1985 opening of a blood products laboratory to treat and screen blood.

Victims of contaminated blood were treated with contempt—and are still denied justice
Victims of contaminated blood were treated with contempt—and are still denied justice
  Read More

A note from him said she “should stay clear of Aids (!) even when it is a question of opening laboratories to help innocent victims”.

Fowler said the virus was not a priority for the government, and that Thatcher vetoed a ministerial statement on HIV and Aids.

He also admitted that the government dragged its feet in changing its insistence that there was “no conclusive proof” that HIV could be transmitted through blood products.

It was already known by November 1983 that two haemophiliacs, including one who’d died, had been diagnosed with Aids.

It wasn’t until the mid-1980s that the department of health insisted that all blood products be heat treated.

Fowler’s evidence shows how the prejudice surrounding HIV/Aids in the 1980s combined with penny-pinching to deny those infected with disease in NHS hospitals any compensation.

His admission piles yet more shame upon the Tories. 


Click here to subscribe to our daily morning email newsletter 'Breakfast in red'


Mobile users! Don't forget to add Socialist Worker to your home screen.