Socialist Worker

Scotland the brave?

Are workers more militant north or south of the border, and what is the relationship between nationalism and radicalism? asks Gregor Gall

Issue No. 1974

illustration by Tim Sanders

illustration by Tim Sanders


Across the Scottish political spectrum, there is common recognition of an ingrained left of centre political culture, comprising egalitarianism, social justice and collectivism.

Indeed, this political culture has become a major part of what people in Scotland think it is to be Scottish. Consequently, the evidence for this Scottish popular radicalism is often defined by comparison to people in England or the rest of Britain.

There is certainly support for this view of Scottish radicalism from social attitude surveys in the last 30 years.

People in Scotland have shown greater support on issues such as workers’ rights and nationalisation. The same is true with social justice issues such as reducing unemployment and increasing wealth redistribution.

Further, people in Scotland more often identify themselves as working class than people do in England. Proportionately these people in Scotland are more likely to vote Labour than those who identify themselves as working class in England.

Lastly, people in Scotland are more likely to identify themselves as Scottish than those in England are to identify themselves as English — Britishness is much stronger in England than in Scotland.

So is it a case of “Scotland the brave” then? The evidence for Scottish popular radicalism holds true when the comparison is between Scotland and England, or between Scotland and the rest of Britain. The pattern does not hold nearly so true when the comparison is between Scotland and Wales, or between Scotland and Northern Ireland.

Although comparing Scotland to England appears plausible, it takes no account of other important forms of identity and cleavages such as class. Neither does it take into account significant internal geographical variations. Much of Scotland’s character is influenced by the “Central Belt”, and particularly Greater Glasgow. The same point can be made about England and the influence of London and the south east.

Even when still taking Scotland as a single unit, more appropriate and productive comparisons can be made between Scotland and various individual regions of England like the north west.

So when the radicalism of Scotland is compared to other similar areas, in terms of their population sizes, industrial structures, workforce composition and political heritages, we get a much better sense of where Scotland stands.

On workers’ rights and social justice, people in the northern half of England show similarly left wing views to those in Scotland. In terms of union membership, collective bargaining and strikes since 1979, Scotland has seldom been out of the top quartile in the league table of the twelve government regions of Britain.

So Scotland is clearly more red and radical than London and south east England. But it is no more red and radical than the north east of England, the north west, Yorkshire and Humberside, and Wales. Indeed, on these latter measures, the north west of England is probably more red and radical.

What these areas have in common is that they are communities of collectivism, where relatively strong combined social networks of trade unionism, labourism and communitarianism allow mobilisations in defence of left of centre values.

But even then, these other red geographical regions still lack what Scotland has — a tight fitting together of national identity, social democratic values and radical behaviour. This helps creates a tangible but unjustified impression of unceasing radicalism from Red Clydeside to the poll tax rebellion, without regard to the quieter periods and the ups and downs in the struggle.

Figures such as John MacLean and Tommy Sheridan then take on an iconic status.

The fusion of left leaning views and national identity has also taken little notice of the decline in the evidence of radicalism since 1979. This is indicated by falls in union density and strike rates across Britain, because the previous differences — such as Wales, the north of England and Scotland being more strike prone then elsewhere — have been maintained.

The key explanation for prevalence of this radicalised conception of Scottishness lies in the way in which opposition to the Tories was organised into a broad cross party and cross class coalition by the labour movement between 1979 and 1997.

Now, with Labour in government in Scotland and Britain, it will be interesting to see if this sense of Scottishness fades away or continues to express opposition to values of neo-liberalism, the free market and individualism of New Labour. The fortunes of the Scottish Socialist Party will be important in determining the outcome here.

Gregor Gall is author of The Political Economy of Scotland — Red Scotland? Radical Scotland? University of Wales Press, price £19.99. Order copies from Bookmarks, phone 020 7637 1848 or go to www.bookmarks.uk.com


If you enjoy Socialist Worker, please consider giving to our annual appeal to make sure we can maintain and develop our online and print versions of Socialist Worker. Go here for details and to donate.

Article information

News
Sat 29 Oct 2005, 00:00 BST
Issue No. 1974
Share this article


Tags



Mobile users! Don't forget to add Socialist Worker to your home screen.