Downloading PDF. Please wait... Issue 2811

Israeli government collapse is rooted in the racist state’s foundations

Prime minister Naftali Bennett was forced to dissolve government after failing pass a law that upholds Israeli occupation and apartheid
Issue 2811
Image of Israeli president Bennett at a meeting with US leaders

Israeli prime minister Naftali Bennett  (Picture: James K. Lee)

Israel’s government has collapsed. The occupation of Palestine—and the very existence of the Israeli state itself—are at the heart of the crisis.

Right wing prime minister Naftali Bennett was forced to dissolve his government on Wednesday. He failed in his attempt to renew a law that extends Israeli civilian rule to its citizens in West Bank settlements.

The law was a cornerstone of Israel’s apartheid system as it privileges Israeli settlers over West Bank Palestinians, who live under military rule. Every Israeli government—and most Israeli parties—have voted to renew it every five years ever since Israel invaded and occupied the West Bank in 1967.

But Bennett’s government narrowly lost the renewal vote on its first reading in June—and looked set to lose a further vote on Friday. That would have left more than 475,000 Israelis in West Bank settlements living under the same military law as Palestinians. Rather than risk that, Bennett chose instead to dissolve the government. 

For most Israeli politicians, this had nothing to do with principle or opposition to settlements. The bill would have passed if it wasn’t for the viciously right wing opposition led by former prime minister, racist warmonger Binyamin Netanyahu.

As prime minister, Netanyahu championed settlements in the West Bank. He didn’t want to end them—but to prove that Bennett’s government can’t manage the occupation. That’s a fundamental question that strikes at the very existence of the Israeli state—and is at the root of Israel’s political crisis. 

Israel’s settlement-building campaign is designed to claim Palestinian land—with a view to eventually annexing it—and deny Palestinians the hope of any kind of state. But annexing Palestinian land also means more Palestinians living inside Israel’s border. The prospect of this is an existential crisis for a state premised on maintaining a clear ethnic majority over Arabs.

Every Israeli government has had to face up to this contradiction—and none has found an answer.  Bennett’s coalition government replaced Netanyahu a year ago this month. It ended a two-year-long stalemate in which four elections had failed to produce a government.

The one thing that every party in Bennett’s coalition agreed on—“left” and right—is that Netanyahu could no longer manage the occupation. He is bogged down in multiple corruption scandals. But—more importantly—last year’s Palestinian revolt had rocked Israeli society.

Yet those parties were also split on how to manage the occupation and preserve Israel as a “Jewish” state. Some of them are so-called “centrist” or “left” parties who think a commitment to some sort of Palestinian state is the best way to keep Arabs out of Israel.

Others—such as Bennett—want to annexe the whole of the West Bank. They were also divided on what Israel’s “Jewish identity” should mean. Some are secular and want to end privileges enjoyed by Israel’s orthodox minority, while others are deeply religious.

That left Bennett’s coalition fragile and vulnerable to splits—and Israel’s political system mired in repeated elections and stalemates. The only near certainty is that any outcome will likely mean intensified repression of Palestinians. 

Bennett and Netanyahu are committed to never letting go of Palestinian land. Their answer is to do their best—through settlement building and violent repression—to force Palestinians into ever smaller enclaves.

Israeli mainstream politics once denied the crisis had anything to do with the occupation. But now the truth is coming to the fore—it’s about a racist state that can’t exist without oppressing Palestinians.

Sign up for our daily email update ‘Breakfast in Red’

Latest News

Make a donation to Socialist Worker

Help fund the resistance
One-off