
Protests against Binyamin Netanyahu are a sign of Zionism in crisis
After a year of Israel’s genocide in Gaza and its invasion of Lebanon, it can feel like an all-powerful state. But the Zionist project is in crisis.
Israeli society is beset with division. In late August demonstrations of 500,000 Israelis protested against Binyamin Netanyahu’s government. Israel’s apartheid “trade unions” called a general strike. And division has wracked state and military institutions.
More fundamentally, Israel has not been able to destroy Hamas and has no “end game” in Gaza. Israel has extended its war to Lebanon. But Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982 and 2006, only to see forces of resistance gain in support and return to battle.
In 76 years, Israel has been unable to overcome resistance from the Palestinians nor establish stability for itself in the Middle East. And globally, the pretence that Israel is anything other than an apartheid, terror state has been torn aside.
The crisis of the Zionist project is threefold. Firstly, an internal crisis within the settler colonial state. Secondly, a crisis of the imperialist order in the Middle East. Thirdly, a crisis born of Israel’s inability to subdue Palestinian resistance.
Israel’s founders aimed to establish an entirely Jewish settler state with the backing of imperialist powers. This involved the ethnic cleansing of 750,000 Palestinians, 80 percent of the population, through mass terror in Nakba of 1948.
Unlike some other settler states, the aim was not to exploit the indigenous population but to drive Palestinians from the land altogether. Israel’s founders believed that in this way they could solve any “Palestinian problem”.
After 1948, some 20 percent of Israel’s population were Palestinians, falling to as low as 11 percent as new waves of settlers arrived. Israel was able to control this population, through military rule, repression and a degree of incorporation into the social structure as second-class citizens of the state.
However, from the late 1960s, this “status quo” fell apart. In the Six Day War of 1967, Israel seized and occupied the West Bank and Gaza. This was territory, populated by over a million Palestinians, including refugees from the Nakba. Five days after Israel’s victory, foreign minister Abba Eban warned ministers of a “barrel of dynamite” in imposing Israel’s rule over the Palestinian territory.
Today, the Zionist project—which aimed to settle a land emptied of Palestinians—finds itself having to mount a permanent state of siege against a Palestinian population numbering almost six million. That’s approaching the number of the Jewish population itself.
After the 1967 war, Israel faced a mounting campaign of armed struggle waged by the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO).
In 1982, Israel invaded Lebanon to crush the PLO and its Muslim and left allies. Tens of thousands were killed, including over 3,000 Palestinian refugees massacred by Israel’s Lebanese proxies in the camps of Sabra and Shatila. The PLO suffered defeat and was forced into exile in Tunis.
Yet within five years, the Palestinian resistance erupted in new form in the First Intifada in the West Bank and Gaza. To quell Palestinian revolt, the United States brokered the Oslo Accords in 1993. This harnessed the PLO into collaboration with the Israeli regime through the Palestinian Authority, as Israel escalated massive new Jewish settlement of the West Bank.
As the mirage of Palestinian statehood disappeared, the Second Intifada of 2000-2005 erupted followed by the shock victory of Hamas in the elections of 2006. Israel imposed a blockade and launched repeated attacks on Gaza in 2008, 2012, 2014, and 2018-19, killing thousands amid vast destruction.
Yet Palestinian resistance continued—including the Unity intifada of 2021 which united the Palestinian population across the whole of historic Palestine. Every strategy to force the Palestinians into submission has ended in failure.
Those attempts finally came crashing down on 7 October, which was a direct result of the ongoing violence and ethnic cleansing for over three quarters of a century.
With every eruption of resistance—and Israel’s failure to subdue it—the settler colony’s population has swung toward an ever more open expression of racist ideology. Today the most right wing section of Israeli society are Israeli youth, who have come of age since the Second intifada.
Labour Zionism, which dominated Israel’s government, state and military from the state’s foundation for decades, is dead.
In addition, each new wave of settlers has generated competing claims in establishing their position within Israeli society. This has given rise to an array of political parties, each seeking to assert specific interests and extract concessions or privileges. These divisions have been sharpened by the crisis of the project itself.
The forces of far right Zionism wish to dispense with the Palestine Authority altogether, and annex the entire territory from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean. They are the driving force behind the current onslaught on the West Bank by the military and settlers.
The religious and nationalist right also draw support from Israelis of north African and Middle Eastern origin. The “Mizrahi” Jews, who came to Israel in the 1950s and suffered discrimination and contempt from the European Zionist establishment.
The Zionist establishment, Israel’s military chiefs and intelligence agencies share the right’s determination to crush Palestinian resistance. But they are concerned with Israel’s “legitimacy” and the regional consequences of dispensing with the fig leaf of “occupation” and establishing a formally constituted apartheid state. These rival forces are also deeply divided over plans for “the day after” in Gaza.
Yet the stark reality is that neither camp has a realisable “end game”. Hamas has not been destroyed. Egypt and the Arab rulers oppose the “transfer” of Palestinians for fear of the survival of their own regimes. The Israeli military and intelligence chiefs are opposed to permanent occupation and re-settlement of Gaza. Even if they wished to, escalating the genocide to many hundreds of thousands would threaten revolt in the region and mass mobilisations globally.
It is this deadlock that has fuelled the toxic divisions within the Zionist state and the mass protests calling for a ceasefire deal with Hamas to free the hostages. Yet these protests are in no sense anti-war—nor are they concerned with Palestinian deaths. In fact, Netanyahu and his party Likud have regained popularity since June and the assassinations of Hamas and Hezbollah leaders.
In the latest polls Netanyahu has again passed his main opposition rivals. Netanyahu has escaped pressure from the US to negotiate a ceasefire deal, and at least temporarily, consolidated the rival Zionist camps.
However, the inability to resolve the crisis has consequences for the imperialist order in the Middle East and for the Arab regimes. Israel’s unique state structure as a settler colonial society has made it an indispensable pillar of the imperialist order. Unlike the Arab regimes, it is not vulnerable to revolt from below.
US commitment to Israel’s so-called “Qualitative Military Edge” (QME), is enshrined in US law. QME refers to “Israel’s ability to counter and defeat any individual state, coalition of states, or non-state actor, while sustaining minimal damages or casualties”.
From a position of strength, Israel has secured alliances with important Arab states. Israel secured successive agreements beginning with Egypt after the 1973 war, then with Jordan, and more recently, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Morocco and Sudan.
In October 2023, the US believed it was on the verge of securing the real prize—a deal between Israel and Saudi Arabia. The 7 October attack by Hamas and the aftermath put paid to that.
The US is now even more reliant on Israel than in previous decades and has less influence over its actions. US dominance has weakened against other imperialist rivals and over Arab states in the region. A crucial issue for the US is to counter the rise of Iranian power after the US disaster in Iraq. It also faces “overstretch” in Ukraine and the South China Seas, in shoring up its military weight against China and Russia.
And beneath these multiple interacting crises the spectre of revolt and revolution in the Middle East haunts the imperialist order and the Zionist settler project. That does not mean the settler state will auto-destruct from within. Rather, with no “end game” in sight Israel ramps up war, genocidal violence and terror. The Palestinians and the masses of the Middle East pay the price.
This cannot be resolved by the US and its allies nor by the Arab rulers. It is a crisis that must be brought to an end by revolution in the region and mass revolt in the heart of the imperialist beast.
A necessary step towards working class power
Glasgow service users and workers speak out
An interview with historian and author Martin Empson and a review of the new film The Uprising